Head-to-head

Farberware Classic Yosemite Percolator (8 cup) vs Presto 12-Cup Electric Percolator (02811)

Stovetop against electric: the two classic ways to make percolator coffee.

Kettle & Crema is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works.

Farberware · Budget

Farberware Classic Yosemite Percolator (8 cup)

Strong, hot camp-style coffee on a stove or campfire, with no electricity.

Check price on Amazon.comRead the full review →
Presto · Budget

Presto 12-Cup Electric Percolator (02811)

Families and gatherings that want hot, strong coffee kept warm at the table.

Check price on Amazon.comRead the full review →

Side by side

Farberware Classic Yosemite Percolator (8 cup)Presto 12-Cup Electric Percolator (02811)
Price tierBudgetBudget
Capacity4–8 cups, up to 64 fl ozUp to 12 cups
MaterialStainless steel—
HobsGas and electric; check the listing for others—
CareDishwasher safe—
Speed—About a cup a minute (maker’s figure)
Keep warm—Automatic
Features—Ready light, detachable cord, removable basket
Biggest strengthNo electricity neededHands-off percolator coffee
Biggest drawbackEasy to over-brew and make bitterCoffee is strong and can taste bitter

Choose the Farberware Classic Yosemite Percolator (8 cup) if…

  • You want to brew on a stove or campfire without electricity.
  • You make four to eight cups at a time.

Choose the Presto 12-Cup Electric Percolator (02811) if…

  • You want the timing handled and the coffee kept warm.
  • You make up to 12 cups for a group.

Our verdict

For camping and stovetop brewing, the Farberware. For gatherings at home, the Presto.

Farberware Classic Yosemite Percolator (8 cup)Check price on Amazon.com
Presto 12-Cup Electric Percolator (02811)Check price on Amazon.com

Our comparisons are research-based, drawn from published specifications, certification, repair information and long-term owner feedback. How we research.